Digital Critique Terms

Last updated November 3, 2026

These terms cover every Digital Critique purchase from Journey to Kidlit. This includes our Children’s Book Manuscript Review, the monthly reviews included for the Kidlit Community, extra critique rounds, and the Editor Review. When you check out, you agree to these terms.

The Children’s Book Manuscript Review

The Children’s Book Manuscript Review is our Digital Critique for children’s book writers. Each Children’s Book Manuscript Review includes 2 manuscript rounds:

  • Round 1: a digital critique of your story, plus 1 follow-up question about your critique
  • Round 2: a follow-up review of your revision, open for 30 days after your critique

Your critique comes from Glenda, our digital critique partner, built on the Story Foundation’s signature critique method and powered by Claude, made by Anthropic.

Glenda never writes, rewrites, or suggests words to put in your story. She gives you feedback, the same way a human critique partner or editor would, and you do all the writing. Using Glenda does not mean your story is AI-generated. Your manuscript is 100% your work.

Your critique notes are always guidance on ways to improve your story, not a required edit. If any suggestion doesn’t fit your vision for your book, you do not have to use it.

What you can share

  • Picture books: your full manuscript
  • Chapter books, middle grade, and YA: up to 3,000 words (usually about 10 pages or one chapter), pasted into the portal. You can also share your synopsis or outline.

When to use it

Start your Children’s Book Manuscript Review within 90 days of purchase. Reviews that aren’t started within 90 days expire.

If you have more than one review in your account, the portal always uses the one that expires soonest first. If we can’t critique what you shared (for example, it isn’t a children’s book manuscript), we’ll explain why and your review will be credited back into your account for you to submit something different.

Kidlit Community members

  • While your membership is active, you get a Children’s Book Manuscript Review every month: a digital critique plus a follow-up review of your revision.
  • Your review resets on your monthly renewal date (not the 1st of the month) and doesn’t roll over, so use it before your next renewal date.
  • Your follow-up review stays open for 30 days from your critique, even if that goes past your renewal date.
  • If you cancel, your monthly review and any open follow-up review end on the last day you’ve paid for. Extra critique rounds you bought keep their full 90 days.

Extra critique rounds

Want feedback on another story or a new section? You can buy extra critique rounds one at a time from your portal. Each one adds another Children’s Book Manuscript Review to your account: a digital critique plus a follow-up review of your revision. Kidlit Community members get the member price while their membership is active. Each extra critique round must be used within 90 days of purchase.

Editor Review

Want an expert’s opinion? You can add an Editor Review to any critique. A member of our editing team reads your story and your digital critique from that session, which we pull from the portal, so you don’t need to resend anything. You’ll get written feedback from your editor, including their suggestions for your next steps, within 1 to 2 weeks. We’ll email you when it’s ready. An Editor Review doesn’t use one of your manuscript rounds.

If something goes wrong with your critique

If your feedback isn’t about your book, your reviews aren’t showing, or a session didn’t finish, click “Report an issue to the team” in your portal, or email hello@journeytokidlit.com. Tell us which session it’s about.

Our team will look into it within 24-72 hours. To review your session, we’ll read what was exchanged, including anything you submitted and any notes sent. If it didn’t work the way it should, we’ll make it right by fixing it or returning your review.

All sales are final

Digital Critique purchases are non-refundable once checkout is complete. If a session doesn’t work the way it should, we’ll fix it or return your review (see above).

Your work stays yours

  • You keep all rights to everything you write and share. Your feedback is yours to use however you like.
  • You give Journey to Kidlit permission only to store your work securely and use it to give you feedback.
  • Your writing is never used to train AI, by us or by the companies we work with.
  • Your stories are saved securely in your account so Glenda can remember them. No one on our team reads your stories or your digital critiques unless you report an issue, buy an Editor Review, or opt in to our beta check.
  • We never share your writing or use it in our marketing without your written permission.
  • Please share only writing that’s your own.
  • Your writing is encrypted while it’s stored.
  • Our emails never include your writing or your feedback. They only let you know your feedback is ready.
  • The portal has no advertising trackers.
  • If our technical team ever has to fix a problem, they only look at what’s needed to fix it. We may also share information if the law requires it or to protect someone’s safety.

How long we keep your work

Your stories and feedback stay in your account while you have access, and for 12 months after your last paid access ends. We’ll email you before anything is deleted. You can ask us for a copy of your stories, or ask us to delete them, anytime at hello@journeytokidlit.com. Deleted work is removed from our live systems right away and from all backups within 30 days. We keep billing records (never your writing) as long as tax law requires.

Our beta check (through December 31, 2026)

During our beta, our team spot-checks a few digital critiques after the feedback is sent, only to ensure the outputted feedback aligns with our editing team’s response. It never delays or changes your feedback. If you’d rather not participate in the beta check, you can opt out by checking “Leave my stories out of the beta check” when you set up your account. Starting January 1, 2027, our team only reads a session when you report an issue or buy an Editor Review.

Who can buy

You must be 18 or older to buy a Digital Critique and use the portal.

Changes to these terms

We may update these terms from time to time. If a change affects reviews you’ve already bought, we’ll email you first.

Questions? Email us at hello@journeytokidlit.com.